The Good, The Bad & American Rugby | November 2026
The USA Men’s Eagles have plenty to celebrate. Five consecutive victories, an undefeated Nations Cup campaign, and their pool championship secured with a convincing 53–24 victory over Romania in Bucharest. Seven tries and a 29-point winning margin are encouraging results for Scott Lawrence and his coaching team.
Saturday’s match against Georgia in Tbilisi will be very telling for both teams. Both are undefeated in the Nations Cup, with Georgia ranked 13th in the world and the Eagles 15th. The result will give us a good indication of where our men’s national team stands and whether we’re ready for the next level.
Three Competitive Tiers
The world’s leading rugby nations fall into three reasonably distinct competitive groups.
| Competitive tier | Countries |
|---|---|
| Tier 1 — Established powers | South Africa, New Zealand, Ireland, France, England, Scotland, Australia, Argentina, Wales* |
| Tier 2 — International challengers | Fiji, Japan, Italy |
| On the Bubble | Georgia |
| Tier 3 — Emerging competitors | Portugal, USA, Spain, Tonga, Chile, Samoa, Uruguay |
Wales nearly warranted a separate tier between the established powers and international challengers after its recent decline. But Saturday’s 35–28 victory over New Zealand demonstrated that it still belongs among the established powers.
I’ve been watching Nations Championship and Nations Cup matches simultaneously on separate screens this November. The difference in speed, physicality and intensity is striking. Saturday’s England–Japan match illustrated that gap. England scored 13 tries in a 78–15 victory over Japan, despite Japan competing in the higher-level Nations Championship. Japan had an early red card, but the result was still emphatic. Just two months ago, Japan defeated the Eagles 63–14.
Punching Above Your Weight
What distinguishes Fiji, Japan and Italy is their ability to punch above their weight. Consider some of their significant international results:
| Nation | Notable results |
|---|---|
| Fiji | England 30–22 (2023); Australia 22–15 (2023); Wales 24–19 (2024); Scotland 29–14 (2025) |
| Japan | Wales 24–19 (2025); Italy 27–10 (2026); Fiji 20–15 (2026); USA 63–14 (2026) |
| Italy | Wales 24–21 (2024); Australia 26–19 (2025); Scotland 18–15 (2026); England 23–18 (2026); France 13–13 (2024)* |
| Georgia | Italy 28–19 (2022); Wales 13–12 (2022); Japan 25–23 (2024); USA 43–30 (2025) |
Italy’s 13–13 draw with France in the 2024 Six Nations is included as a notable result rather than a victory.
Clearly, at present, we have no realistic chance of competing with South Africa, New Zealand or any of the Tier 1 nations. But we must aspire to compete consistently with Fiji, Japan and Italy.
Georgia: The Next Step
Several years ago, Georgia would have belonged alongside Fiji, Japan and Italy in that second tier. Recent results have been mixed, raising questions about whether Georgia has maintained that standard.
Georgia defeated Japan 25–23 in 2024 and narrowly lost to Italy 20–17. Last year it beat the Eagles 43–30 but lost to Japan 25–23. This March, Georgia lost to Portugal 19–17, but has since won five consecutive Nations Cup matches, including Saturday’s 55–31 victory over Tonga.
The Eagles have beaten Georgia before, but their most recent victory was in 2013. Georgia’s record makes it an excellent measuring stick for the Eagles.
What Should We Expect from Our Eagles?
We should expect the Eagles to beat teams ranked well below us and to do so convincingly. We should beat teams like Hong Kong China comfortably, and victories over teams like Romania should be expected every time we play them. Saturday’s 53–24 victory over 23rd-ranked Romania was the kind of performance we should expect.
Our earlier results need context. The Eagles were missing numerous players through injuries and international availability when they lost 61–12 and 52–0 to Australia XV in October. Several overseas-based internationals returned for the narrow 28–26 victory over Hong Kong China, with more available against Romania.
We’ve also had some meaningful victories. The Eagles defeated Samoa 29–13 in September 2025 to secure qualification for the 2027 World Cup. But Japan’s 63–14 victory over the USA in this year’s Pacific Nations Cup semifinal demonstrates the gap between our current level and the nations we’re aspiring to join.
The Eagles made considerable progress during the 2010s, highlighted by their historic 30–29 victory over Scotland in 2018. Eight years later, I find it frustrating that we’re still competing in the middle of this lower tier. We followed that historic win with defeats to Scotland of 42–7 in 2024 and 85–0 in 2025. Eking out a two-point victory over Hong Kong China last week only reinforces that frustration.
We should be further along. Identifying young talent and providing a development pathway with increasingly higher levels of competition is essential to preparing players for international rugby. How we accomplish that deserves a separate discussion.
Our expectations must be higher than simply beating lower-ranked opponents. We need to convincingly beat those around us and increasingly challenge the nations above us. Scott Lawrence’s Moonshot 2031 goal of reaching the Rugby World Cup quarterfinals on American soil will require exactly that.
Looking Ahead to the 2027 World Cup
Our 2027 Rugby World Cup pool includes France, Japan and Samoa. France presents an enormous challenge, while Japan represents the competitive level we’re trying to reach. Samoa is strengthening its squad with former All Blacks Akira Ioane, Josh Ioane and Shaun Stevenson, along with former Wallaby Scott Sio.
We beat Samoa last year, but its strengthening squad makes the next encounter particularly interesting. Holding Japan close and beating Samoa would give us an excellent opportunity to advance to the knockout rounds in Australia.
A Chance to Make a Statement
Georgia is a very good rugby team, playing at home, with a recent victory over the Eagles. It’s going to be tough to beat them in Tbilisi.
A victory would be a significant statement. A competitive performance, even in defeat, could demonstrate progress against a team that beat us by 13 points last year.
The Eagles deserve credit for their undefeated Nations Cup campaign, but our expectations must extend beyond winning matches against lower-ranked opposition.
We must become consistently competitive with Georgia, Fiji, Japan and Italy. That’s the next level for American rugby, and Saturday’s match will give us a good indication of how close we are.