American Rugby’s Competitiveness Problem Reply

As part of my research for The Good, The Bad & American Rugby, I came across an excellent podcast made this week featuring former 34-cap Eagle Juan Grobler, who scored the USA’s only try against eventual champions Australia at RWC1999. Juan joins Springbok great Naas Botha and Ryan Grobler for a discussion about international rugby and why the United States struggles to compete at a high level, like the recently concluded series v Australia A. Interesting to see this issue being discussed on Drop In, one of South Africa’s prominent rugby podcasts.

The central point is one any follower of American rugby should recognize: American players don’t get enough consistent exposure to high-level competition.

I experienced this firsthand. Two weeks before earning my first cap against Australia at RWC1987, I was playing club rugby for Old Puget Sound Beach, with a handful of spectators on the sideline. Two weeks later, I was facing the Wallabies on my debut at Ballymore. The gulf in the levels of competition and speed of play, was staggering.

Nearly 40 years later, we confront the same problem.

Major League Rugby (MLR) has provided professional opportunities for American players, but the standard of competition simply isn’t consistently high enough to prepare them for Tier 1 international rugby. Watching some of our better MLR players struggle against Australia A this weekend reinforced that point.

This isn’t the players’ fault. Rugby players cannot perform consistently at a level they rarely experience. The pace, physicality, decision-making, and execution of basic skills required internationally are developed through regular competition against quality opposition. There is no substitute.

Money is a huge part of the problem (and a big thank-you to all MLR owners who continue to invest, despite severe obstacles to profitability). MLR operates with limited financial resources compared with established professional leagues overseas. This affects the quality and depth of squads, coaching, and ultimately the standard of competition. USA Rugby faces similar financial limitations in assembling and preparing national teams to compete internationally. This gap in resources only grows with each passing year, as ‘the rich get richer’.

See Italy’s participation in the URC, Argentina’s Jaguares previous involvement in Super Rugby, and Japan’s increasingly competitive League One. These competitions provide regular exposure to a very high standard of rugby and directly contribute to national-team development.

The podcast also raises the lack of a meaningful Under 21 competition structure in the USA which is prevalent overseas. Outside the collegiate system, the pathway from high school into senior rugby remains limited. College teams bar very few get consistent high level competition. The scorelines of games played by the top teams often are at a minimum 50 point deficit. I see Army West Point Mens Rugby (my Alma mater) scores regularly in the 70-5 range and cringe knowing this does not improve the standard. It’s fun to post a huge score line on social media, but there is no benefit to the quality of play. This lacuna does little to develop top players, ready to compete at a high level at a relatively young age.

Watching the Eagles in recent weeks, we’ve heard all about “developing players” from Coach Lawrence , but selecting young players isn’t the same as developing them. It’s not Scott’s fault either. He can only work with what he is given.

The immediate future looks difficult.

At RWC2027, the Eagles face France, Japan, and Samoa in what is shaping up to be an extremely difficult pool. Japan continues to benefit from its strong professional competition and players coming through the New Zealand rugby system. Samoa is strengthening its squad with former All Blacks, including Shaun Stevenson, Akira Ioane, and Josh Ioane. This will be a Samoa team not seen in decades.

For the Eagles, any victory in that pool would be a huge accomplishment.

For RWC2031 on American soil, we still have five years to address these shortcomings. But any plans and implemented systems mean little unless they improve the standard of rugby our players experience on a consistent basis.

This is exactly the kind of issue I’ll be exploring in The Good, The Bad & American Rugby: the circumstances that have shaped the competitiveness of our national teams, not simply their wins and losses.

We need our best players playing better rugby, more often. Until we find a way to make that happen, the gap isn’t going to close.

Well worth a listen.

🎧 Drop-In Podcast — Episode 35, featuring Juan Grobler, Naas Botha and Ryan Grobler

Why I’m Writing The Good, The Bad & American Rugby. Reply

My ‘Why’

As we begin building “The Good, the Bad & American Rugby”, I want to share the purpose behind this project.

Like so many rugby players — whether club, representative, or national team — I’ve stood at gatherings where stories flow as freely as the drinks. It might be a match, a wedding, or, sadly, a funeral. Every time, laughter and tears mingle as teammates recall the moments that shaped them. And inevitably, someone says, “We need to document these stories. They have to live on.”

I’ve felt that same pull for years. The shared experiences of American rugby — its triumphs, heartbreaks, and humor — deserve to be preserved. Yet there is no comprehensive record of our national teams, Men’s or Women’s, XVs or 7s. No formal documentation exists.

This book, The Good, The Bad & American Rugby, is my attempt to fill that void. It will capture the stories behind the matches, the personalities who shaped the game, and the culture that binds us. It will include reference materials, images, and historical documents that trace our journey from the gin‑infused watermelon at the founding of the USARFU in 1975 to the upcoming 2031 and 2033 World Cups on American soil.

In addition to the stories and tales, the book will explore the off‑field circumstances that ultimately affect the performance of our national teams on the field — the unseen forces that shape outcomes and opportunities. These include influences such as the Golden Eagles’ funding and its impact on the national 7s program, the role of Title IX as a catalyst for the women’s game, the loss of elite college football athletes in the 1970s, and the 2020 bankruptcy of USA Rugby. Each of these moments tells a deeper story about how culture, policy, and economics intersect with sport.

I want this work to stand as a legacy — a record of where we’ve been and how we got here. I hope it introduces new readers to the sport and reminds longtime players why rugby matters. The good and the bad, the laughter and the tears — all of it deserves to be remembered.

That is my why.