Full three-frame USA versus Georgia match sequence fitted inside a social media landscape image.

Georgia 38 v USA 10 – Losing Is Acceptable. Lack of Intent Is Not. Reply

I accept why the Eagles struggle against teams ranked above us. As a national Union, we lack resources, our player development pathways remain questionable, our players don’t get enough high-level competition, and the MLR season is too short and lacks consistent intensity. Missing players because of Regulation 9 issues and others not released by their French clubs doesn’t help either.

It’s acceptable to lose to a better, higher-ranked team. However, Saturday’s 38–10 loss to Georgia was particularly frustrating. Both teams entered the final round of the Nations Cup undefeated at 5–0, having won their respective pools. After five straight victories, including an impressive win over Romania, I was looking forward to seeing how we matched up against stronger opposition than we have faced in this competition.

In my preview of this match last week, I discussed that Georgia would be an excellent measure of how far the Eagles have progressed. Unfortunately, Saturday’s performance gave us a pretty clear answer.

In the opening exchanges, I was extremely disappointed with our lack of endeavor. Newly capped scrum-half Oscar Lennon launched at least five box kicks in the opening ten minutes. Outside-half Chris Hilsenbeck never touched the ball during that period, other than fielding an up-and-under (quite well). Our centers didn’t touch the ball until well after that.

I felt like I was watching England in the 1970s or 1980s, when constant Garyowens were the preferred method of advancing the ball. Suffice to say, boring. I’m fine with boring rugby when it’s effective, and there’s certainly a place for tactical kicking, but surely we can find a way to get our backs involved.

Our first two scrums looked strong, but we struggled as the match progressed. As in previous games, we continued to lose possession in the tackle or at the breakdown when attacking inside or just outside Georgia’s 22. At this level, every possession must be treated like gold.

Even when Georgia were down to 14 men following a yellow card, we elected to take three points rather than press our numerical advantage. There’s nothing wrong with taking points when they’re available, but in a match where we are looking to make a statement, I found the decision disappointing. It seemed another example of playing not to lose rather than trying to win.

With four minutes remaining, trailing 38–10, we were still kicking possession away long downfield. Our lack of attacking intent was significant.

In any match, I watch players’ body language and how they carry themselves on the field. The signs are telling. One of my pet peeves about modern rugby is watching players throw their arms in the air, begging the referee for a penalty as though they’re entitled to something, rather than playing to the whistle.

Three-frame sequence showing USA scrum-half Oscar Lennon appealing as Georgia win possession.

The accompanying image shows Lennon coming off the left wing with both arms raised, appealing for a penalty as Georgia win the breakdown. The Eagles were trailing 26–3. Not two seconds later, Georgia attack right past Lennon on the way to an uncontested try.

Completely preventable had Lennon been concentrating on his job rather than appealing to the referee. Down 23 points, it’s simply unacceptable.

In the post-match interview, I was puzzled by captain Jason Damm’s comment about pushing Georgia to the limit. I found it quite disingenuous. Honesty must be the order of the day. We simply weren’t good enough. Just say it.

The five victories preceding this match deserve recognition, and Scott Lawrence and his players deserve credit. But the real measure of progress is how we perform against stronger opposition. Georgia has built an impressive international program, and this was our opportunity to demonstrate how much progress we’ve made.

I accept the Eagles losing to Georgia. It was always going to be a tough ask, particularly in Tbilisi. However, any USA supporter should expect us to show some attacking ambition, play with urgency, and compete until the final whistle. We may not have the resources to beat Georgia and other higher-ranked teams consistently, but we must show some intent in trying.

Leave a Reply